Diesel vs. Gas Trucks: Which is Right for You?

Do you need a new truck but don’t know whether to get diesel or gas? Many shoppers find themselves in this predicament since diesel and gas trucks are broadly similar in terms of purpose and overall design. While there are a few similarities between the two types of trucks, there are also some significant distinctions in their purpose, fuel efficiency, engine performance, torque power, maintenance costs, and more.


Advantages of Diesel Trucks

Diesel trucks offer numerous advantages over standard gasoline trucks. Among them are:

  • More torque and towing power: Diesel engines have higher compression ratios and larger displacement than gasoline engines, allowing them to produce more energy from each fuel combustion cycle. As a result, it increased torque which allows for greater hauling capacity.
  • Higher gas mileage: Unlike gas-powered trucks, diesel vehicles are often up to 35% more fuel efficient, meaning you can put more miles onto your truck without taking a large scratch on your wallet. Cost savings associated with higher fuel efficiency can add up over time, allowing you to save even more money for more important things like regular maintenance and emergency repairs.
  • Longer-lasting performance: Diesel trucks provide greater performance and last significantly longer than their counterparts. Their engines and their accompanying fuel tanks are made to be heavy-duty, meaning they can handle more wear and tear over time without suffering too much damage or undergoing potential engine failure. This is highly beneficial no matter how you use the truck, whether on the job site, on long road trips, or on everyday errands.

Advantages of Gas Trucks

Gas trucks quickly become the preferred choice for commercial fleets, offering several advantages. These include the following:

  • Lighter and faster: Gas trucks are more advantageous than their diesel counterparts as they are lighter in weight, which allows them to accelerate more quickly. This can be beneficial in tight terrain or when fast maneuvering is necessary. This speed advantage may also help save money on insurance premiums, adding further savings.
  • Better at handling heavy payloads: This makes gas trucks ideal for motorists who conduct a lot of heavy hauling. Gas trucks also have powerful engines under the hood, which make them ideal for carrying heavier weights than a standard vehicle. Also, due to their larger size and prolonged wheelbase, the gas truck has improved stability over longer distances, providing an overall better ride quality. With these vehicles, people can transport goods and items much faster and with less risk of damage or an accident occurring.

Choosing the Right Engine for Your Needs

Both diesel and gas trucks have their advantages and disadvantages, but ultimately, the choice of which is the best and right for your needs comes down to your preferences and requirements. However, you can easily finalize your choice by understanding their differences based on a few factors below.

  1. Nature of applications- Depending on the purpose for which it will be used, fuel economy and efficiency may become more important than power for some applications. If you have less demanding use, such as hauling smaller loads or plowing a driveway in a ski town, you may pick a quieter and more efficient gas engine. In contrast, diesel applications could be better suited to some types of towing or rugged terrain.
  2. Usage- If you’ll need to use the truck for several hours a day for either highway or off-road applications, then opting for a diesel truck is likely your best option. Diesel engines are known for their superior performance in heavier workloads, and their longer engine life makes them an excellent choice for those needing to use their vehicle extensively. On the other hand, if you require only occasional use, a more cost-effective gas engine could provide more than adequate performance at much lower running costs. 
  3. Fuel economy- Diesel trucks are typically known to consume fewer gallons per mile than gasoline-powered trucks. In addition, diesel engines produce more torque, offering drivers enhanced towing capabilities and performance. So if you’re looking for added power and greater fuel efficiency, then diesel is likely the best option. 
  4. Long-term savings- Diesel engines generally have higher upfront costs than gas trucks due to their more intricate parts. Despite that, they often produce more horsepower and deliver excellent fuel efficiency. This makes gas trucks cost-effective in the short term, but a diesel engine may provide more significant, long-term savings due to its better fuel economy and longer engine life.

While those factors can help you decide which one is better, evaluating your specific needs is what matters most. For instance, if you prefer a gas-powered truck since it is faster and easier to maneuver, but you really need a vehicle that can withstand rough terrain, it might be best to give up the former and instead choose a diesel truck based on your needs. Assessing your requirements ensures that it will not only help you avoid wasting money and dealing with regrets but also equip you with an engine that offers reliable performance and serves the right purpose.

Which Truck Is More Environmentally Friendly: Diesel or Gas?

Diesel engines have long been known for their remarkable fuel efficiency, making them an increasingly popular choice for drivers looking to reduce their emissions and save money on energy costs. In addition, a recent study found that diesel engines emit significantly lower amounts of CO2 and Greenhouse Gases (GHG) than conventional gas engines. This finding has caused many governments and environmental organizations to recommend diesel trucks as a more environmentally responsible option. With the shift towards diesel engines due to their lower impact on the environment, it is clear that investing in this type of vehicle is beneficial not only to your finances but also to the environment.

What Are Some Drawbacks of Diesel Trucks and Gas Trucks?

Driving a diesel and gas truck can be a great experience, but as a driver, you should be aware of the drawbacks associated with it. The following list contains the significant downsides you should know.

Diesel Trucks

  • Increased cost – The initial price of this car is usually higher than that of a gas-powered vehicle, and this can make purchasing a diesel truck difficult for budget-conscious motorists. It is generally accepted that diesel trucks are 25-30% more fuel efficient than gasoline vehicles, but with this increased efficiency comes an increased price tag. For example, a diesel-powered truck can cost anywhere from $5,000 to $11,000 more than a similarly sized gasoline-powered truck. 
  • Specialized maintenance – Diesel trucks often require maintenance which adds to their total upkeep costs. For instance, a typical oil change for a diesel truck costs between $60 and $80, while gasoline trucks range from $20 and $40, depending on the engine size. 
  • Create louder noise – Driving a diesel truck isn’t always as enjoyable since they tend to create louder noise than their gasoline counterparts. This can be especially annoying for those who live in densely populated neighborhoods. 

Gas Trucks  

  • Shorter engine life – Gas trucks have shorter engine life when compared to diesel models due to worn parts and poorer quality internal components. Gasoline engines are much more prone to wear and tear, requiring frequent repairs and maintenance.
  • Reliability issues – Poor fuel mixtures may easily cause damage to the engine system and significantly lower its reliability levels. Gasoline engines are also more susceptible to cold stalling and breakdowns, which can cause costly delays in your journey.
  • Less fuel-efficient – Gas trucks can lack efficiency with increased fuel consumption under full-throttle conditions due to larger amounts of compression. This can lead to increased emissions and higher energy costs over time.

While these drawbacks are not expansive for all gas and diesel trucks, potential owners should consider the other factors above before purchasing to ensure that they match their requirements.

Final Thoughts

Weighing the benefits and drawbacks of diesel and gas trucks before making a final decision is important. Diesel trucks offer better fuel economy, longer engine life, and lower emissions but may come with a higher purchase price tag. Comparatively, gasoline-powered vehicles can provide more power output at a lower cost of ownership but are less efficient in fuel consumption and require more frequent maintenance to keep them running optimally. While they both offer good and bad sides, it’s then crucial to assess your specific needs and the money you’re willing to spend upfront, as they can significantly help you decide which is right for you.


  1. https://www.trustedchoice.com/insurance-articles/wheels-wings-motors/buy-diesel-car/#:~:text=Pros%3A%20Lower%20fuel%20cost%2C%20higher,diesel%20mechanics%20are%20more%20expensive
  2. https://www.progressive.com/answers/pros-and-cons-of-diesel-cars/
  3. https://www.westernmotorslosbanos.com/diesel-vs-gas-truck/
  4. https://www.lynchtruckcenter.com/manufacturer-information/diesel-vs-gas-trucks/#:~:text=While%20diesel%20trucks%20tend%20to,depend%20completely%20on%20your%20needs.
  5. https://rentar.com/diesel-vs-gasoline-pickup-fuel-mileage-emissions-fun-comparison/#:~:text=Diesel%20engines%20produce%2025%25%20to,gallon%20than%20their%20gasoline%20counterparts.
  6. https://www.worktruckonline.com/156593/diesel-or-gasoline-making-the-right-decision
  7. https://bestsellingcarsblog.com/2022/08/media-post-cost-of-owning-a-diesel-truck-vs-gas-things-to-consider/
  8. https://www.azocleantech.com/article.aspx?ArticleID=1580
  9. https://youmatter.world/en/diesel-or-petrol-what-pollutes-more/#:~:text=Diesel%20Engines%20Emit%20Less%20CO2,efficiency%20of%20the%20diesel%20engine.
  10. https://bestsellingcarsblog.com/2022/08/media-post-cost-of-owning-a-diesel-truck-vs-gas-things-to-consider/
  11. https://vehicleanswers.com/why-diesel-trucks-expensive/

About the author, Laurence Perkins

Laurence Perkins is the passionate car enthusiast behind the blog My Auto Machine. With over a decade of experience in the automotive industry, Perkins has knowledge and experience with a wide range of car makes and models. His particular interests lie in performance and modification, and his blog covers these topics in-depth. In addition to his own blog, Perkins is a respected voice in the automotive community and writes for various automotive publications. His insights and opinions on cars are highly sought-after.